DeWalt vs Makita Impact Wrenches for home garage - which would you pick?

Hey folks, I'm looking to upgrade my impact wrench for automotive work in my home garage. I've narrowed it down to DeWalt's DCF891B 1/2" and Makita's XWT14Z. Both seem solid, but I'm torn. I do everything from brake jobs to occasional suspension work. Anyone have long-term experience with either? I care about durability and power more than price.

DrillMaster943, I've owned both (well, similar models) and here's my take: DeWalt's brushless motor is a beast, but Makita's ergonomics are better for tight spaces. Price-wise, you can often catch DeWalt on sale at Home Depot. Makita batteries tend to last longer in my experience though. If you're budget conscious, check refurbished units - I got my DeWalt impact for 40% off that way.

Safety note first: both brands meet ANSI standards, but Makita's anti-vibration tech is slightly better documented. I've inspected shops using both - DeWalt's trigger control is more progressive, which matters for lug nuts. Makita's quick-release chuck has fewer pinch points though. For home use, either is fine, but if you're working on aluminum wheels, go with the smoother torque curve (Makita in this case).

Thanks both! Pete - good tip on refurbs, I'll check that out. Gary - didn't even think about vibration for long sessions. Follow-up: how's battery compatibility? I have some older DeWalt 20V batteries, but Makita's LXT system seems more universal. Any issues with either brand's battery contacts corroding in a garage environment?

DrillMaster943 - Your old DeWalt batts will work but might not deliver full power. Makita's LXT is indeed more cross-compatible across their tools. As for corrosion, both have decent seals, but I'd recommend storing batteries inside regardless. Pro tip: buy the bare tool and get aftermarket batteries from a reputable seller - saved me a bundle on my Makita setup!