DeWalt DCF887 vs Makita XDT16: Which Impact Driver is King?
5/14/2026 9:00:00 AM
#1
LevelLarry429
New Member
Posts: 0
Hey guys, I'm a DIYer trying to pick between the DeWalt DCF887 and the Makita XDT16 for general home stuff and maybe some deck building. I've heard good things about both. Anyone have experience with either? Pros/cons?
5/14/2026 10:54:00 AM
#2
WrenchWendy614
New Member
Posts: 0
I'm a garage gearhead and I've used both. DeWalt feels more ergonomic to me, but Makita's 3-speed power is insane. If you're doing a lot of framing or heavy lag bolts, Makita wins. For lighter duty, DeWalt's fine.
5/14/2026 11:04:00 AM
#3
RenovationRick733
New Member
Posts: 0
As a pro contractor, I've beat the crap out of both. XDT16 has better battery life and stays cooler under heavy use. DeWalt's chuck is slightly better for bit retention. I'd go Makita for the long haul.
5/14/2026 10:03:00 AM
#4
WrenchWendy253
New Member
Posts: 0
I'm with Rick. Makita's build quality is unmatched. Plus the XDT16 has that Auto-Stop feature that saves your wrists if the bit binds. Worth the extra cash IMO.
5/14/2026 10:44:00 AM
#5
LevelLarry429
New Member
Posts: 0
Thanks for the input! Leaning toward Makita now. Is the XDT16 compatible with the older 18V batteries? I have some from my drill set.
(You must be logged in to reply)