Forum > Screwdrivers

Deck build: Cordless screwdriver vs impact driver - which one?

7/30/2026 3:55:00 PM #1
DeckNewbie
DeckNewbie
Guest
Posts: 0
Hey everyone, starting my first deck build next weekend and I'm torn on what screwdriver to get. I already have a 18v drill but no impact driver. Should I just use the drill with a driver bit, or is it worth getting a dedicated impact driver? Also, any specific models you'd recommend for framing and decking screws? Budget is kinda flexible if it's worth it.
7/30/2026 5:35:00 PM #2
DrillMaster15
DrillMaster15
New Member
Posts: 0
Honestly, for a deck you NEED an impact driver. That's non-negotiable. Your regular drill will strip heads and you'll be fighting it all day. I run Dewalt 20v XR all day, every day. The DCF887 is a beast but if you're ballin' on a budget, the older DCF885 still works. But if I were you, I'd grab the 887 and don't look back.
7/30/2026 6:23:00 PM #3
MakitaMike721
MakitaMike721
New Member
Posts: 0
Listen, I've been framing decks for 20 years. DeWalt is fine, but Makita's impact drivers are the gold standard. The XDT16 is my go-to. But more important than the brand: get one with a brushless motor and 3-speed settings. You'll want the slow speed for precise driving to avoid splitting the wood. And yeah, an impact driver is a must. Your drill will burn out with those 3-inch screws.
7/30/2026 9:49:00 PM #4
DIYDave820
DIYDave820
New Member
Posts: 0
I'm with DrillMaster on Dewalt. But also, don't forget about the bits! Get a good set of Robertson bits (square drive) if you're using deck screws. They don't cam out. And if you want to save some cash, look for a combo kit drill+impact. You can find deals on Amazon or big box stores. But like Mike said, features matter. Get something with a variable speed trigger and a clutch if you can.
7/30/2026 5:39:00 PM #5
DIYDave472
DIYDave472
New Member
Posts: 0
If you're just doing one deck, you don't need to drop $200 on a top-tier impact. I've built two sheds and a paver walkway with my $40 Ryobi from Home Depot. It's done the job. But I'll echo what everyone said: use the impact, not the drill. And make sure you pre-drill if you're going near the edge of the lumber. Happy building!

(You must be logged in to reply)